Downton Abbey Wiki
Register
Advertisement

"If you're tired of style, you're tired of life."
—to Elsie Hughes[src]

Charles Ernest[2] Carson (b. 1856[1]) was the butler of Downton Abbey and began working at Downton Abbey as a Second Footman at the age of 19.[1] He lived at the estate to witness the birth of Robert and Cora's three daughters: Mary, Edith and Sybil.

In May 1925, he married Elsie Hughes, the head housekeeper at Downton. Seven months later, he handed in his resignation, after suffering from palsy, where Thomas Barrow took his place as the butler.

Biography[]

Background[]

In 1870, Charles Carson arrived at Thrushcross Grange near Ripon aged 14 to take up the position of Junior Hall Boy under the direction of the butler Alfred Beet. Carson loved approval from Beet who he described as "the sternest butler I ever encountered" and felt his approval a prize in itself. Through his five years at Thrushcross he progressed to the positions of Hallboy to Nursery Footman and finally Fourth Footman looking after the master's Clocks. At age 19, and sometime around 1875, he left to become second footman to the Earl of Grantham, where he quickly rose in the ranks to become butler.[1]

Between 1870 and 1875, Carson was on the stage, (or "on the halls" as his former colleague, Charles Grigg said), as a song-and-dance double act called, The Cheerful Charlies. He recalls this part of his life with little nostalgia, however. He admitted that he once had a close romance with a young woman and colleague, Alice Neal.

1912-14[]

Carson brings up the newspaper and a telegram to Lord Grantham, both of which deal with the sinking of the Titanic, on which both James and Patrick Crawley were sailing.

Carson receives a letter, and is acting strangely and has been taking food from the larder. It is revealed that Charles Grigg, his former stage partner, has come to the area and has been blackmailing Carson for food and money. He has been threatening to expose his past as a member of the duo The Cheerful Charlies and make Carson a laughing stock. He later shows up at Downton Abbey, and Carson tells Lord Grantham that he will resign, but Robert refuses to accept his resignation. Everyone who learns of it is surprised or even amused that Carson was once a theatrical performer, but Carson thinks it a affront to the dignity of his job. Robert gives Grigg £20 to go away, and threatens him with arrest if he returns.

Carson discovers that someone has been stealing wine, and later one of Lord Grantham's snuffboxes goes missing. Carson rounds up all the servants and searches rooms, but finds nothing. The snuffbox reappears and Daisy says that she saw Mr Bates take the wine. Daisy later admits that she was pressured to lie by Thomas, who was also seen by Joseph Molesley lifting Carson's wallet. Lord Grantham and Carson decide to fire Thomas, but he resigns to join the army medical corp., before they can carry this out.

1916-19[]

The First World War has come to Downton and the young men have all enlisted. Carson is appalled that maids must serve at dinner. Carson takes many of the duties around Downton on himself and overdoes it.

Downton is turned into a convalescence hospital for the duration of the war, to allow the hospital in the village to deal with critical patients. Thomas begins managing this aspect of Downton, much to Carson's consternation as it makes him Carson's superior.

Carson gets an offer from Richard Carlisle to be butler for him and Lady Mary after their marriage, and Carson is torn, as he is fond of Mary, but still loyal to her father and Downton. He decides to reject the offer, after he learns that Carlisle tried to pay Anna to start spying on Mary. He cannot work for a man that he doesn't respect.

Like several others at Downton, Carson contracts the Spanish Flu, and his illness allows Thomas to gain employment back at Downton as a footman.

1920[]

When Mary descends the staircase in her wedding gown, she first asks Carson affectionately if he thinks she will do. He replies "Very nicely milady."

He does not at first believe that Alfred, Miss O'Brien's nephew, should have been hired as he is too tall and too inexperienced. Carson is indignant about every mistake he makes. Over time, however, as he sees how diligent Alfred is, he takes Alfred under his wing and starts to teach him.

He insists that everything must be done properly for Edith's wedding even though the house is understaffed. When he discovers that Mrs Hughes may be seriously ill, Carson shows a great deal of concern, and he is overjoyed to the point of singing to himself when he learns that she'll be alright.

When Thomas's unwanted homosexual advance on Jimmy is reported to him, Carson responds with revulsion and says that Thomas is "foul". Carson will allow him to resign with a reference, but only as he wants him to go quietly. When threatened by Jimmy that Thomas must have no reference, or he will go to the police, Carson reluctantly gives in to this. Only the intervention of Lord Grantham and Bates saves Thomas' job. When asked who will tell James that Thomas is staying, Carson says that Lord Grantham wants him to stay so he should tell James.

Mr Carson is rather frustrated when Tom Branson returns to the house as the husband of Lady Sybil. After Tom is exiled, he tells Mrs Hughes he knew that Tom would bring shame and dishonor on the house. He is later deeply affected, as are the rest of the staff, by Sybil's death following complications from childbirth. Over time, he comes to respect Mr Branson even more, and comes to accept him as a member of the family.

2012 Christmas Special[]

While the family goes to Duneagle Castle in Scotland, Carson presides over the house. He remains behind when they all go out to a fair in Thirsk, knowing none of them would have fun if he went (which he acknowledges only to Mrs Hughes). He takes the time to bond to Lady Sybil's daughter. Mrs Hughes praises him for doing so. He later agrees with Mrs Hughes that maid Edna Braithwaite has to go after she unsettles the other maids and makes unwanted advances on Mr Branson.

1922[]

When Lord Grantham insists on keeping Mary sheltered following her husband's death, Tom goes to Carson as he feels he does not know who else to turn to. He insists they need to help bring Mary back to the world. Out of love for Mary, Carson tells her she is letting herself be defeated. She is angry at him for doing this, but later breaks down and cries in his arms.

Charles Grigg writes to Carson saying he has ended up in the workhouse and needs help. Carson, still upset with Grigg, throws the letter in the trash. But Mrs Hughes finds it, reads it, then finds Grigg and sets him up at Isobel Crawley's house for a time. Carson is upset at what she has done, but she insists he needs to stitch up this "open wound" and asks if he feels nothing for this man he sang and danced with.

It is revealed the split between Carson and Grigg was a woman they both loved, Alice Neal, who chose Grigg. When Grigg gets a job and prepares to leave, he bids Carson farewell at the train station. He reveals that Alice died five years ago, but they split up long before. But he tells him she told him Carson was the better man. They shake hands, and later Mrs Hughes gives Carson a portrait of Alice to put on his desk.

When Edna Braithwaite returns to be Cora's maid, O'Brien having left, both Tom Branson and Mrs Hughes are upset. She insists that they cannot have her back at the house, but Carson says they must. He feels that her ladyship having already lost a daughter and son-in-law, it would be too much for her if she felt that Lady Sybil's husband was "unworthy". He also notes that Edna seems to have gotten some training and perhaps she has entered the real world. Mrs Hughes nevertheless is afraid her return is a ticking bomb, which proves to be true when Edna heartlessly tries to seduce, then blackmail Tom. Fortunately she manages to save him and send Edna away again. Carson expresses regret only for the disruption to her ladyship but admits he never cared much for Edna. Mrs Hughes tells him he'll feel less sorry when she tells him the whole story one day, and that they were mad as hatters to let her back in the house.

Carson continues to express a longing for the past at Downton and resisting change, such as when Nellie Melba and Jack Ross both come to Downton. However he admits Ross was a decent fellow, and praises England leading the world in the fight against slavery. Still he is not a fan of the jazz music that plays that night.

When Alfred decides to pursue cooking, Carson encourages him, saying he is a hard worker. Later, when Alfred does not get accepted, Carson insists he keep working hard, and later praises him for expressing gratitude for the kindness he received from him and the family after he replaces a candidate who dropped out. He says gratitude is what he likes to see. When Molesley initially hesitates to replace Alfred as a footman (something Carson thought he would not do considering his difficulty finding work), Carson is really upset with him and refuses to take him on even when Alfred does leave. Unfortunately for him, Mrs Hughes and Mrs Patmore fight in Molesley's corner, and Carson relents.

2013 Christmas Special[]

Carson treats the staff to a day out at the seaside (after his other options of different museums attracted none of their interest), and in a tempting of things to come, Mr Carson holds Mrs Hughes's hand as they go into the sea together.

1924[]

Carson is asked to be the Chairman of the War Memorial in Downton Village, instead of the more obvious and traditional choice of Lord Grantham. Despite the committee's insistence that Carson is better suited for the post, as he knew the soldiers and their families, he insists that His Lordship be made Patron, else he will not serve. During the course of his chairmanship, he faces difficulties deciding where the Memorial ought to be held and goes head to head with His Lordship, as well as Mrs Hughes. (He would like to create a Garden of Remembrance, while the others want a stone edifice in the centre of the village.) After a disagreement with Mrs Hughes however, Carson is quick to acquiesce, and he tells her that the bonus of his changing his mind is that they are on the same side once more.

Later on in the series, Mrs Patmore attempts to convince him (through Mrs Hughes) to include her nephew, Archie Philpots in the Memorial, to which Carson strongly disagrees with. He feels that it would be disrespectful to the men that stayed and fought for their country, to include a soldier who had been shot for cowardice. This causes some discomfort between the Cook and himself, and so he makes a special effort to support and advise her when she is considering investing in a property.

Inspired by their visit to Mrs Patmore's cottage then, Carson nervously asks Mrs Hughes if she would consider investing in a property with him. His idea is that they could rent it out or run and Bed and Breakfast, so that they might increase their savings by the time they retired. While her answer to him is not direct, it is clear that she is overcome by this business proposal, and that she thinks his intentions might be to venture farther than that in the future.

2014 Christmas Special[]

After viewing a number of cottages together, Mrs Hughes tells Carson that she did not have the money to invest in the first place, although she would have liked to come in with him, had she been able. Ashamed and almost heartbroken, it is strongly suggested here that his intent had always been to share the project with her especially, and to possibly retire together one day. Carson is sad, but not resigned, because he believes he can still try to ask her what he had long been waiting to ask. In fact, at the end of series five and during the Christmas Eve party, he asks Mrs. Hughes to talk privately. Then they go to the butler's room and he tells her that he has bought a cottage for both of them. She replies that she doesn't know what would happen in the future and that if he wanted to change his life one day, he would be stuck with her. But Carson replies again: "But that's the point. I do want do be stuck with you." Mrs. Hughes remains impassive and wide-eyed, stating that she is not sure she has understood correctly. So he adds: "You are if you think I'm asking you to marry me." She is still amazed, but after a while she happily confirms that she will marry him, saying: "Of course I'll marry you, you old booby. I thought you'd never ask!". So, after 5 seasons and 12 years on the show and maybe more years of their working relationship that we didn't see at Downton, the two finally confess how they feel about each other. Then they toast together and then they come back upstairs with all the others to wait for Christmas day.

1925[]

Mrs. Patmore goes twice to speak with Carson on behalf of Mrs. Hughes regarding the wedding. Carson doesn't initially understand what that means, but when his head clears up, he feels embarrassed. In fact, he hasn't thought of everything that involves getting married and living together, when Mrs. Hughes had worried about it and she doesn't want to feel absurd in her husband's eyes. So, on the night of the celebrations for Anna and Bates' release from trial, they talk about the matter in a room and Carson tells her that if she had second thoughts about the wedding and no longer wanted to marry him, he would have accepted it. However, Carson had misunderstood, and together they hold this conversation, directly from Episode 6.01: Carson: Right, well, shall we rejoin the others?

Hughes: Before we do... I know I've been putting you off... and Mrs Patmore spoke of your conversation.

Carson: I knew she would. I hope we've not shocked you between us.

Hughes: No, I'm not shocked.

Carson: I thought it better to be honest. Once you'd raised the matter.

Hughes: I agree, much better.

Carson: I wouldn't want you to think that I'd inveigled you into an arrangement which was not what you'd expected.

Hughes: I would never think that.

Carson: Right. Well, if you've had second thoughts, I think we should let the staff know in the morning. I won't make a big announcement. We'll just tell one or two people and let it come out naturally. There'll be a bit of a nine days' wonder, of course, but we'll get over it.

Hughes: But you misunderstand me. I was afraid I'd be a disappointment to you. That I couldn't hope to please you as I am now. But if you're sure...

Carson: I have never been so sure of anything.

Hughes: Well, then, Mr Carson... If you want me, you can have me. To quote Oliver Cromwell, warts and all.

Then, they share their first kiss together. A few days later there were the wedding in the Church, while the reception is in the schoolhouse. Back from their honeymoon, they find the servants' rooms decorate for them. Meanwhile, there are several events in their new house, like him stating that his wife does not cook as well as his mother, but to this he and the cook, convincing indirectly Carson to prepare dinner for a few evenings, leaving him speechless and taking care of his "intolerance"ntowards the housekeeper's kitchen. Later, nearer to the end of the series, Carson has a shaking in his hands and confesses to Mrs Hughes what it is, however he can do nothing more to keep working, so Lord Grantham decides that Thomas will be the new butler, while Carson will continue to taking care of some homework from his cottage with his wife. After that, Robert infinitely thanks him for all he has done for them over the years and the butler is moved and proud to have used his service as good as he did. Then, at midnight, the servants sings "Auld Lang Syne", ending the amazing show.

Personality[]

Carson is a man who takes his job seriously. He is very strict about the standards at Downton, and is upset whenever they are disrupted or breached by his coworkers. However, he does have a deep respect and admiration for the Crawley family and others of the "upstairs" world. Mrs. Hughes accuses him of worshiping them.[3] Despite his stern exterior, he shows almost fatherly concern for his coworkers. Thomas is surprised to see him teaching Alfred about spoons, as he had never done anything like this for Thomas. Carson replied that Thomas had never asked. Though he is determined that they ensure that the house is run efficiently, and they never seek to cause trouble. He is initially against the employment of Mr. Bates because he believes that his lameness will cause dissension as others will have to do his work for him, but later admitted he could not imagine Downton without him. Like Lord Grantham, he has difficulty accepting change and takes great pride in Downton Abbey and what it symbolizes. Despite his personal beliefs, he will put the honour of the house before them, such as loathing Thomas Barrow's homosexuality, but wishing to see him go quietly without bringing scandal to the house.

ThCA3J8ZRB

Carson with Miss Sybil Branson.

Actor Jim Carter has stated that Carson sees upstairs and downstairs as two completely separate worlds, which is why he is upset when Lady Sybil marries Tom Branson, the former chauffeur. He can however be a surprisingly kind man, such as when he called Tom's respect for Cora's invitation for Kieran Branson "exemplary" and when he shows a preference for Alfred over Jimmy even though Jimmy has had more experience as a footman than Alfred despite being angry at Alfred for his past errors. To those to whom he is close, he is always extremely concerned when they might be in serious trouble, such as when Mrs. Hughes might have had cancer. He also has a very loving side, such as when he comforts Lady Sybil's daughter. Most of his soft and loving side comes with Lady Mary, who Carson dearly loves as a daughter, always caring about her and treating her kindly since she was a child.

Politically, Carson is a monarchist, loyal to and proud of the British monarchy. He also detests being called "liberal."

Carson is also a man of great culture, he often borrows one or two books from the library and enjoys cultivating his self-knowledge. Through the series he is constantly seen mentioning and quoting several historical characters of Europe and mostly from England, he is also aware of famous actors and actresses of theatre which surprises those around him such as Mrs. Hughes. He can also show some wisdom and offer good advices to others, like when he adviced Lady Mary to be honest and express her feelings to Matthew before he departures to war so she doesn't have regrets in the case he died in battle. He can be sometimes flexible about formalities, though in very rare ocasions, such as allowing Alfred to openly insult Anthony Strallan after he left Edith jiltered at the altar.

Relationships[]

Mrs Hughes[]

Mr. Carson often at the end of each day shares moments with the housekeeper, Mrs. Hughes. They meet in her sitting room or his pantry and talk about how the day went. They are very different, she is much more practical about the job and accuses him of worshipping the Crawleys. He cares about her, this is seen when he learns that she does not have cancer and is moved to hum a cheerful song. It has long been suspected that he has harboured feelings for her since very early on in their working relationship. When Carson bought a house to live in, he registered it in Mrs. Hughes name as well and soon proposed to her to which she gladly accepted. They were married a short time later.

Lady Mary Crawley[]

Mr. Carson loves Lady Mary like a daughter and has comforted her on many occasions. When she was remembering the night she spent with Kemal Pamuk and how she regretted it, he told her that she was still very young to which she replied, "Am I? I don't feel it." When at the garden party in 1914, she accepted Matthew Crawley's proposal to her but he turned down her response as he felt it had taken too long and she wasn't sure enough, he comforted her and she said tearfully, "Don't worry, Carson. I'm never down for long."

Downton Abbey Lady Mary and Mr

Mr. Carson consoling Lady Mary after she has been refused by Matthew Crawley at the 1914 garden party.

When she became engaged to Sir Richard Carlisle, Mr. Carson knew that Mary was not happy like she should be. When he had a heart problem and she came to see him, he told her to tell Matthew that she loved him. "Then even if he is killed," Mr. Carson reasoned, "You won't be sorry. If you don't tell him, you could regret the rest of your life." Mary wanted to follow Mr. Carson's advice, but after having a conversation with Lavinia Swire, Matthew's then fiancee, she discovered how much Lavinia loved Matthew and decided against taking Carson's advice. Sir Richard Carlisle asked Mr. Carson to be the butler at Haxby, which was going to be his and Mary's house when they were married. Mr. Carson accepted, feeling he could help Mary "in
Downton abbey lady mary wedding dress

"Will I do, Carson?" -Lady Mary Crawley

those early years when it's important to get it right" to use his words. Mrs. Hughes asked him if he would like it over at Haxby, and would he regret leaving Downton, to which Carson replied, "I will regret it every moment of every day," he said, but his sense of loyalty to Mary propelled him to Haxby. However, when Anna told him that Sir Richard had tried to bribe her into spying on Lady Mary, he took back his word, feeling he could not "work for a man [he] didn't respect." Lady Mary was completely disappointed in him and hurt him with her harsh words. "And I always thought you were fond of me!" Carson's look of heartbreak at this moment clearly said it all: He felt she should not be marrying Sir Richard and only wanted her to be happy. When Carson contracted Spanish flu in 1919 and Lady Mary broke off her engagement in January 1920, they forgave each other.

Lady Mary was married in spring 1920 and as she walked down the stairs in her wedding dress, both Robert and Carson looked up to her, eyes full of pride. "Will I do, Carson?" she asked him, smiling. "Very nicely, my lady," he answered, eyes glistening.

When she was about to have her baby in September 1921, Carson was in a feverish mood ("Who wouldn't be, after Lady Sybil?" he says to Mrs. Hughes, referring to Sybil's disastrous birth of her daughter and how he does not want the same thing to happen to Mary). Upon learning she had given birth successfully he was so happy he forgot to ask what sex the baby was.

After Matthew Crawley died, it was Carson, together with her grandmother Violet Crawley and Tom Branson, who encouraged her that she was strong enough to carry on.

Sybbie Branson[]

When Lady Sybil Branson, Sybbie's mother, died in July 1920, Carson broke down and expressed grief. In September 1921, when Sybbie's nanny was not there, Sybbie started to cry. Carson picked her up and soothed her in the library. He told Mrs. Hughes when she came in that he was remembering Lady Sybil when she was Sybbie's age (a little over a year old at the time).

Robert Crawley, Earl of Grantham[]

Carson and Robert have known each other for decades, since Carson arrived at the age of 19 to work for Robert's father, the 6th Earl of Grantham. Since Robert became the new Earl, Carson has been serving as his right hand and confidant. Unlike with the rest of the family, they have a more casual relationship, with Robert treating Carson more like a close friend rather than a servant, and Carson is usually seen talking and sharing his opinion. Robert is seen quite protective with him, like when he threatened Charles Grigg with calling the authorities if he didn't leave Downton at once and refusing to accept Carson's resignation. On the other hand, Carson has the outmost respect and loyalty to Robert which he genuinenly appreciates. Most of the time, Carson and Robert are seen confiding things only to each other, such as when plotted to make Thomas leave Downton after realizing he stole a bottle of wine and blamed Mr Bates of it. Carson also helps Robert as his temporary valet after Mr Bates is accused of murdering his own wife.

Quotes[]

  • "If you're asking, whether I'll regret leaving Downton, I want to regret it every minute of every day. I thought I would die here, and haunt it ever after".- to Mrs Hughes when she asks whether he'll be happy to leave Downton to move to Haxby with Mary and her then fiance Sir Richard Carlisle
  • "May I give you one piece of advice, my lady? Tell him what's in your heart. If you still love him, let him know. And even if he's killed and he may be, you won't be sorry. If you don't tell him, you'll regret it all live long." - building up Lady Mary's self-confidence about her true feeling for Matthew
  • "You're too tall to be a footman. No footman should be over 6 foot 1." - to Alfred Nugent in Episode 3.01.
  • "Where's the style, Mrs. Hughes? Where's the show?" - Episode 3.02.
  • "I thought Mr. Branson's respect for her ladyship's invitation exemplary." - to Mrs. Hughes, showing a respect for Tom Branson he seldom shows.
  • "I've never been called a liberal in my life and I don't intend to start now!" - to Jimmy Kent.
  • "The business of life is the acquisition of memories. In the end, that's all there is."
  • "I'd sooner chew broken glass." -Mr. Carson on not wanting to go to the fair.
  • "If you have a problem with that definition Mr. Barrow, then you can go eat in the yard."

Appearances[]

Appearances and Mentions
Series 1 Episode 1
Appears
Episode 2
Appears
Episode 3
Appears
Episode 4
Appears
Episode 5
Appears
Episode 6
Appears
Episode 7
Appears
   
Series 2 Episode 1
Appears
Episode 2
Appears
Episode 3
Appears
Episode 4
Appears
Episode 5
Appears
Episode 6
Appears
Episode 7
Appears
Episode 8
Appears
Christmas Special
Appears
   
Series 3 Episode 1
Appears
Episode 2
Appears
Episode 3
Appears
Episode 4
Appears
Episode 5
Appears
Episode 6
Appears
Episode 7
Appears
Episode 8
Appears
Christmas Special
Appears
   
Series 4 Episode 1
Appears
Episode 2
Appears
Episode 3
Appears
Episode 4
Appears
Episode 5
Appears
Episode 6
Appears
Episode 7
Appears
Episode 8
Appears
Christmas Special
Appears
   
Series 5 Episode 1
Appears
Episode 2
Appears
Episode 3
Appears
Episode 4
Appears
Episode 5
Appears
Episode 6
Appears
Episode 7
Appears
Episode 8
Appears
Christmas Special
Appears
   
Series 6 Episode 1
Appears
Episode 2
Appears
Episode 3
Appears
Episode 4
Appears
Episode 5
Appears
Episode 6
Appears
Episode 7
Appears
Episode 8
Appears
Christmas Special
Appears
   
The film The film
Appears
 
   

Behind the scenes[]

  • In "The Chronicles of Downton Abbey: A New Era" by Jessica Fellowes and Matthew Sturgis, Julian Fellowes relates that the character of Carson was based on Arthur Inch, a retired butler, now deceased, who served as the principal advisor on the movie "Gosford Park".
  • According to Phillys Logan, who played Mrs Hughes, and Jim Carter, who played Carson, Carson fell in love with Mrs Hughes first, and his feelings for her probably became apparent for the audience, when she had that cancer scare and Carson was very upset about it. Later when they found out she wasn't ill, Carson was so relieved, he sang an old love song.

Notes[]

According to the non-canonical 2015 Text Santa, Carson describes someone as "kind and jolly and, in their youth had a substantial beard" and Robert replies that they "can't ask Mrs Patmore" and Carson protests that he was talking about himself[4].
According to Julian Fellowes, Mr. Carson was given the hereditary nerve disorder essential tremor, a condition from which which the creator also suffers. [5]

References[]

External links[]

Navigation[]

Advertisement